Sayville History Splash: A Glimpse into Cherry Avenue’s Past

Step back in time with this charming old postcard of Cherry Avenue—back when it was known as Cherry Street! This snapshot from yesteryear offers a fascinating look at Sayville’s historic streetscape, lined with homes that whisper stories of generations past.

A Family Home with History
Courtesy of Kathy La Capra, we get a peek at her great-grandmother’s house on the right. The home boasts a grand wrap-around porch and a striking bay window, architectural details that evoke the charm of early 20th-century Sayville. Originally built as a two-family house, the layout was designed with symmetry in mind—the top and bottom floors were identical, mirroring each other in both space and function.

The Van Wyen Family Legacy
The lower level was home to Kathy’s great-grandparents, William H. Van Wyen (August 30, 1873 – March 31, 1942) and Jeannette (Howe) Van Wyen (January 22, 1881 – February 13, 1973). Meanwhile, the upper floor was occupied by Jeannette’s brother and his family. Over time, the upstairs was converted into two separate apartments, one of which became home to a young married couple—Kathy’s aunt (her father’s sister) and her husband.

A Prom Night to Remember
This house also played a role in a sweet Sayville High School love story! Dorathea Magdalene Van Wyen (Class of 1928)—whose photo and story we’ll feature soon—needed a date to her senior prom. Her aunt and uncle, living in the house, stepped in as matchmakers, introducing her to Charles E. Neal, the man who would later become her husband.

This postcard isn’t just a glimpse of a street—it’s a window into the lives, connections, and memories that shaped Sayville’s community. Stay tuned as we dive deeper into Dorathea’s story in the coming days!

Do you have old Sayville photos or memories to share? We’d love to hear them! 📜✨